The system failed Dorene Seidl.
According to this report, not only did a judge deny Seidl's plea for a domestic violence restraining order against her husband - who reportedly had a history of domestic violence and suicidal threats - but authorities also allowed him to keep his firearms.
Yet a week after Seidl told a judge she was "afraid of him and what he could do," her husband allegedly shot her to death.
He reportedly also had a concealed carry permit, which in the eyes of some automatically makes him a "law-abiding gun owner."
He would be at least the seventh concealed carry permit-holder to be charged with murder since July 5.
In the Louisville Courier-Journal:
Earlier this month, Dorene Seidl claimed in a domestic violence petition that her husband, William Seidl, threatened to commit suicide on Aug. 5 and asked her, “Do you want to go with me?” before pulling out a gun.
In her petition, filed in Jefferson Family Court, Dorene Seidl said she had previously removed the bullets from her husband’s gun and, after he tried to get the bullets back, she walked to her daughter’s home and had her call the police.
“In the past, he has put a gun to my head and I knew what he was building his way up to,” Dorene Seidl said in her petition, filed Aug. 7.
But she said police told her William Seidl had a permit for the gun, so there was nothing she could do.
...
In an interview today, [Judge Joseph] O’Reilly said that his prayers are with the Seidl family. O’Reilly said that after listening to an hour of testimony last week, hearing from both of the Seidls and a witness, he could not find by a “preponderance of the evidence,” as required by state law, that domestic violence had occurred.
“I had no legal basis to issue a domestic violence order and I did not,” he said.
Police say that after Dorene Seidl was shot William Seidl, 68, barricaded himself in the home, creating a nearly four-hour standoff with police Monday night.
Dorene Seidl was pronounced dead at the scene about 8 p.m., once the standoff ended, Robinson said. Her husband was charged with one count of murder.
A police citation says that when authorities arrived at Seidl’s residence, he told them that he shot his wife. He also said that they had been having problems and that she came to the house to get personal items when the shooting occurred.
Before the shooting Monday, there had been four previous police runs to the home, police said.
[more]

![Brady Blog [image]](http://www.bradycampaign.org/common-images/page-headers/brady-blog.jpg)


![www.godnotguns.org blog [image]](/xshare/modules/images/gngblog.gif)
![[image]](/xshare/modules/images/gun-violence-map.gif)
![Paul Helmke [image]](/xshare/modules/images/brady-joinus-red-2007-10-12.gif)
![Elections 2008 [link]](/xshare/modules/images/election08-module-brady.gif)
![Gun Industry Watch [image]](/xshare/modules/images/gunindustrywatch-description.gif)
![Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence [logo]](http://www.bradycampaign.org/bradyreport/email/common-images/bc_logo.gif)